BIF Support
IAP Support
Knowledge Exchange
View project by country sector or business model focus
Know-how
Resource Library
Publications
The Hub provides a space for practitioners to connect and gain new insights to help their inclusive business ventures grow. Join now

Hello All,

I’m part of the BIF team in Imani Malawi. I have a particular interest in value chain assessment, market development and environmental sustainability in Malawi. I therefore jumped at the chance to get involved in a BIF cost-sharing project involving these interests - the MicroVentures Programme; part of the work of Microloan Foundation here in Malawi. A summary of the MicroVentures project can be found on http://businessinnovationfacility.org/page/microventures-malawi

My work in the project involved conducting a value chain assessment of Irish potatoes, tomatoes and onions in the MicroVentures focal area of Mzimba District in Northern Malawi. This assessment, with a strong market focus, was the first step towards designing an innovative market linkages model for farmers receiving loans for agri-business from Microloan Foundation. The assessment was critical because I strongly believe that before a programme can be designed the implementing context must be thoroughly understood. The assessment is available to download on http://businessinnovationfacility.org/forum/topics/value-chain-anal....  What I enjoyed most about this piece of work was the opportunity to get right down to the producer level and really understand what was going on in the critical trading centres. Most value chain work I have undertaken has been at the national level and often localised and unique supply and demand patterns can be obscured.

The MicroVentures programme aims to go beyond micro-lending mechanisms to support individual borrowers, and look at the markets where those borrowers sell their products.  Many of you will be familiar with the same problem in other countries: how can small producers access the market, or rather the markets beyond the first trader or nearest town?  It could be said that there is a hierarchy of markets, with the very first trader in the chain being the first tier, and markets further afield becoming increasingly difficult to access.  MicroVentures aims to work directly with smallholders but also the traders and supermarkets. It is a common misunderstanding that greater returns can be delivered to the producer by cutting out the informal middlemen, however this report has found that the trading system is vital for connecting the fragmented producers and holds most of the ‘power’ in the value chain. It is clear that the model for the market linkage must in this context look to incorporate and reform the trading system, rather than bypass it, in order to be viable and effective.

How can we improve the supply chain leading to high value products?  It’s an increasingly enticing question as internal markets change with more value-added products in supermarkets, restaurants/hotels, and so on. The crucial factor for these three commodities is understanding the specifications of the market and ensuring the mechanisms are in place to deliver according to these demands.

I would welcome your thoughts – I know Andrew K in Zambia will recognise many of these challenges as well as the huge potential for new market development, but who else has done something similar? What successes have been seen?  Let me know –

Georgina

Views: 216

Tags: Inclusive supply chains, Malawi, MicroVentures

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of THE PRACTITIONER HUB to add comments!

Join THE PRACTITIONER HUB

Comment by Caroline Ashley, Editor on October 5, 2011 at 9:21
Thanks for these insights Georgie, particularly your though-provoking comments about the need to work with middle-men. There are two other reports on how the poor can upgrade within value chains that I find useful:
1. A new book by my former colleagues at ODI, Jon Mitchell and Chris Coles on Markets and Rural Poverty. There is a good video of their presentations that launched the book, here: http://www.odi.org.uk/events/details.asp?utm_source=event-update&am... . They highlight the need to increase efficiencies and power imbalances, and argue that value chain upgrading is difficult and slow but can indeed raise incomes. And is probably best done when there is a strong business case for other players to invest in the value chain.
2. A report by IIED: Under what conditions are value chains effective tools for pro-poor development? It is in our Resource Gateway here: http://businessinnovationfacility.org/forum/topics/value-chains-for...
BIF work with MicroVentures, Sylva, AACE, AfriNut and others is part of a much bigger global debate about how to address these longstanding challenges.
best, Caroline
Comment by Jack Newnham on October 4, 2011 at 18:05
 

Georgina,

 

Well done for blogging like this - an inspiration to us all (not least me!).

I agree with you that understanding markets as they currently operate is often a key starting point, particularly in informal systems where the market linkages are less clear. I also like the emphasis on traders - and recognising traders and intermediaries as being a part of the market that we are seeking to work with and not a group that we would prefer just not to be there. The MicroVentures project is a good example of a project that needs to consider and address how to work with traders as part of a process of seeking to increase returns for smallholders. In some ways one can see the MicroVentures initiative as a project to incubate a vegetable trading company within MicroVentrues, and potentially cutting out the involvement of traditional traders. However, I would be surprised if traditional traders were not part of the more mature market that we hope will emerge, and one would expect the trading operation incubated within MicroVentures to work with traditional traders as well as directly with smallholder farmers in order to gain scale and reach. If nothing else, at the very least they need to understand how traditional traders operate and it sounds like your value chain work has helped with this.

Feedback Form
Feedback Analytics